Stelle Et putamus quod poena divinae sever...; (De gubernatione dei (439 - 451), Lib. 5, Cap. 8 (p. 62, trans. O'Sullivan, p. 141)) [5879]

Basic Information
Keywords
ID 5879
Text De gubernatione dei (439 - 451) Salvian of Marseilles
Quotation Et putamus quod poena divinae severitatis indigni sumus, cum sic nos semper pauperes puniamus? aut credimus, cum iniqui nos jugiter simus, quod Deus justus in nos omnino esse non debeat? Ubi enim aut in quibus sunt, nisi in Romanis tantum, haec mala? Quorum injustitia tanta, nisi nostra? Franci enim hoc scelus nesciunt. Chuni ab his sceleribus immunes sunt. Nihil horum est apud Vandalos, nihil horum apud Gothos. Tam longe enim est ut haec inter Gothos barbari tolerent, ut ne Romani quidem qui inter eos vivunt ista patiantur. Itaque unum illic Romanorum omnium votum est, ne umquam eos necesse sit in jus transire Romanorum. Una et consentiens illic Romanae plebis oratio, ut liceat eis vitam quam agunt agere cum barbaris. Et miramur si non vincuntur a nostris partibus Gothi, cum malint apud eos esse quam apud nos Romani? Itaque non solum transfugere ab eis ad nos fratres nostri omnino nolunt, sed ut ad eos confugiant, nos relinquunt.
Translation Do we think we are unworthy of the punishment of divine severity when we thus constantly punish the poor? Do we think, when we are constantly wicked, that God should not exercise His justice against all of us? Where or in whom are evils so great, except among the Romans? Whose injustice so great except our own? The Franks are ignorant of this crime of injustice. The Huns are immune to these crimes. There are no wrongs among the Vandals and none among the Goths. So far are the barbarians from tolerating these injustices among the Goths, that not even the Romans who live among them suffer them. Therefore, in the districts taken over by the barbarians, there is one desire among all the Romans, that they should never again find it necessary to pass under Roman jurisdiction. In those regions, it is the one and general prayer of the Roman people that they be allowed to carry on the life they lead with the barbarians. And we wonder why the Goths are not conquered by our portion of the population, when the Romans prefer to live among them rather than with us. Our brothers, therefore, are not only altogether unwilling to flee to us from them, but they even cast us aside in order to flee to them.
Quotation source Lib. 5, Cap. 8 (p. 62, trans. O'Sullivan, p. 141)
Temporal Coverage 439 - 451
Associated use case(s)
Comment